After four years of faithful service, Rev. Russell was succeeded by Rev. Fred Clark in 1924. During that same year, the name of the church was changed to The Antioch Baptist Church. On November 4, 1925, the church was incorporated.
Having fulfilled his duty, Rev. Clark left to serve at another church and was succeeded by Rev. Price in 1926. In the same year, the cornerstone for the building was laid. After Rev. Price served with grace and dignity, he was succeeded by Rev. Turner Elijah who led the congregation for some years.
After Rev. Elijah left the church for a period of time, a number of pastors filled the gap, including Rev. Kelly, Rev. W. McGriff, Rev. Swan, and Rev. J.N. Robertson. Even in the face of trying times, such as the Great Depression and World War II, the church remained strong in faith and in membership.
In 1944, Rev. Elijah returned, and the church experienced its greatest period of growth under his spiritual leadership. The pastor faithfully served God, the church, and the community for eighteen years, until he retired due to ill health in 1962. He was then succeeded by Rev. Laban Wellington.